Sunday, November 22, 2026

SponsorSubscribe

Political Analysis

Granbury’s J-1 Teachers Get a Social Security Exemption Most Texans Never Will

Granbury ISD pitched J-1 teachers as saving FICA, health insurance and TRS, then told trustees TRS was never a saving. The federal Social Security exemption the plan relied on is one most Texans will never get.

The Ledger

4 min read

Granbury ISD's March 6, 2026 memo to trustees correcting its earlier statement that hiring J-1 teachers through International Alliance Group would save TRS costs. Image: Granbury ISD board records.
Sponsor
Universal Coin & Bullion: Thanks, Dr. Mike Fuljenz, for no sales tax on precious metals in Texas

Granbury ISD told its trustees in June 2025 that hiring teachers from overseas through a private recruiter would pay for itself. Nine months later the district went back to the board to say part of that math was wrong. The records, posted to the district’s public board site, show a $9,000 recruiting fee set against $10,000 in savings that the district has since partly withdrawn.

The first memo, from Director of Human Resources Wes Jones to Superintendent Courtney Morawski and dated June 23, 2025, asked the board to approve a host-school agreement with International Alliance Group (IAG), an Arizona company that places teachers in the United States on J-1 exchange visas. Jones wrote that “due to the shortage of bilingual teachers, this agreement provides us with another option for hiring certified bilingual teachers.” The fee to IAG was $9,000, he wrote. “However, after factoring in the savings from not having to pay FICA, health insurance, and TRS for IAG employees, we calculated savings of $10,000, which more than covers the fee.” The request went on the board’s June 23 agenda with the final agreement attached.

On March 23, 2026, the district asked trustees to approve a correction. Assistant Director of Finance Houcine Chraibi wrote that the June characterization “was inaccurate with respect to TRS,” the Teacher Retirement System of Texas, and that “TRS should not have been listed as cost savings.” Granbury is the employer of record for the J-1 teachers and pays their employer TRS contributions, the memo says. A credit on IAG’s invoices labeled “TRS Amount District to Pay” lowers what the district owes the company but “does not eliminate or waive the district’s TRS obligation.” The district also pays for health insurance when a J-1 teacher elects IAG’s plan. The one saving the corrected memo keeps is FICA, the federal Social Security and Medicare tax, because J-1 teachers “are exempt under federal tax law.” It says a detailed fiscal summary is available to trustees on request, and asks the board to keep paying IAG’s invoices.

The agreement itself shows how IAG prices that exemption. Its fee schedule charges the district 20 percent of a teacher’s annual pay while the teacher is exempt from FICA and 16 percent once the exemption ends. The same page explains that J-1 teachers are exempt from Social Security and Medicare for their first two calendar years.

In Granbury, that exemption is worth less than it sounds. Most of the district’s employees already pay no Social Security tax. Its own W-2 guide says “most Granbury ISD employees are exempt from Social Security wages,” because they belong to TRS. What Granbury’s teachers do pay is Medicare, 1.45 percent of wages. During the exemption years, then, the district saves its 1.45 percent Medicare share on a J-1 teacher and pays IAG 4 percentage points more of that teacher’s salary than it would after the exemption ends.

The records were posted on X this week by Nick Plumb, who has asked the district to release its invoices and an updated cost comparison. State Rep. Brent Money of House District 2 shared them, writing that the district planned the hires “because it wouldn’t have to pay FICA, health insurance, or TRS for them, which made them cheaper than Texans.” The district’s own correction now takes TRS off that list.

The federal rule the pitch relied on reaches well past one school district. Under IRS guidance, teachers in J-1 status who have spent less than two calendar years in the United States are generally exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes on their wages. A Texan on a private payroll has no such exemption. Each paycheck sends 6.2 percent to Social Security, and the employer sends another 6.2 percent.

Most Texas teachers already work outside the program. The vast majority of Texas school districts do not participate in Social Security, according to the Texas Classroom Teachers Association, and their employees retire on TRS, a system Texas runs itself. School districts and other local governments that did join cannot leave. Since April 20, 1983, federal law has barred any state or local government covered by Social Security from leaving, according to the Social Security Administration.

The Texas Nationalist Movement calls Social Security “a government-sponsored, government-mandated Ponzi scheme,” one that depends on more workers paying in to cover what was promised to those drawing out. Washington decides who is excused from it, and it excuses a teacher on an exchange visa for two years. A Texan who works for a private employer pays in from the first paycheck to the last, and no one in Granbury or Austin has a vote on whether that ever changes.

Sponsor
Universal Coin & Bullion: Thanks, Dr. Mike Fuljenz, for no sales tax on precious metals in Texas
Share

See more of the Partisan in Google’s Top Stories.Add as a Preferred Source on Google