Senate Budget Chairman’s “Legal Ponzi Scheme” Charge Echoes Miller’s 2018 Book
Senate Budget Chairman Ron Johnson called Social Security a "legal Ponzi scheme" this week. Daniel Miller made the same charge in TEXIT in 2018, and laid out how an independent Texas would protect the benefits nearly five million Texans draw.

Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, called Social Security a “legal Ponzi scheme” on Wednesday and released a chairman’s hearing memo under that title before the committee took up the program. Texas Nationalist Movement (TNM) President Daniel Miller made the same charge in print eight years ago, in his 2018 book TEXIT: Why and How Texas Will Leave the Union.
Johnson told Newsmax on Wednesday morning that the Securities and Exchange Commission defines a Ponzi scheme as a fraudulent investment that pays early investors with money from current ones, “and that’s exactly what Social Security does.” A worker’s payroll deduction, he said, “is spent the minute it comes in on current beneficiaries.”
His memo says the program collected more in payroll taxes than it paid out for most of its history, and that the surplus “was never invested in an asset that had value outside the federal government.” The Social Security Trust Fund itself, the memo says, is a set of special-issue Treasury bonds kept in “a four-drawer file in Parkersburg, West Virginia.” It accuses politicians of both parties of promoting “the fiction” that payroll deductions were being invested in a real asset.
Johnson went further on Fox Business before the hearing. “You can’t fix it. You just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money,” he said, according to Wisconsin Public Radio. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon accused him at the hearing of preferring to shut the program down rather than fix it. Johnson called his remark an “imprecise statement” and said he was not proposing to end Social Security. The memo’s own recommendation is to “repeal that portion of the law that reduces Social Security benefits and quit scaring seniors,” and then turn to federal debt and deficits.
The program’s trustees reported in June that the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund, which pays retirement and survivor benefits, will run out of reserves in the fourth quarter of 2032. Payroll taxes coming in at that point would cover 78 percent of scheduled benefits. The trustees also projected that the program’s total cost will exceed its total income this year and in every year of their 75-year forecast.
In December 2025, 4,996,895 Texans received Social Security benefits worth about $9.38 billion for that month alone, according to the Social Security Administration’s county data. The 3.7 million retired workers among them averaged about $2,034 a month. A 22 percent cut, the shortfall the trustees project for the retirement fund in 2032, would take about $448 from that average check every month. Harris County alone has 650,845 beneficiaries.
Miller wrote in TEXIT that Social Security “amounts to a government-sponsored, government-mandated Ponzi scheme that relies on an increasing number of workers who pay into the system in order to pay out the benefits promised by the self-serving political class.” He warned that workers paying in would one day “be forced to face the fact that they have been participating in a Ponzi scheme,” and cited the trustees’ 2014 projection that the trust funds would be depleted by 2033.
The book also laid out how an independent Texas would handle the program. Any Texan already receiving benefits “should continue to receive them,” Miller wrote, calling that “non-negotiable” because the obligation belongs to the federal government, which already pays benefits to recipients who move abroad. Workers who had paid in would keep their accrued benefits and could choose to keep paying into the federal system or leave it. He proposed opening Texas’ existing retirement systems for state employees and teachers to any citizen, and a totalization agreement of the kind the United States has signed with Canada and Japan, among other countries, so that workers who move between the two would not be taxed twice. If Washington refused to honor its obligations, he wrote, “Texas will always take care of its most vulnerable citizens.”
Johnson’s answer is a change in federal law, and that decision rests with Congress and the president. Texas holds 38 of the 435 seats in the House and two of the 100 in the Senate, so the nearly five million Texans drawing benefits, and the younger workers paying in now, will have a small share of the votes that decide what happens in 2032. Miller’s book argued that Texans should make that decision themselves, keeping the benefits already earned and letting each worker decide whether to stay in a system its own trustees say will run short in six years.
See more of the Partisan in Google’s Top Stories.Add as a Preferred Source on Google
Read Next
Supreme Court Will Decide Whether a President Can Close the Border to Asylum
The Supreme Court took up Mullin v. RAICES, on whether a president may bar asylum at the southern border by declaring an invasion. Texas joined Iowa's brief backing the government and has made its...





